Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Germaine Greer

Shapiro abandons conditional for indicative, sez GG in NS

Germaine Greer hits the ball out of the park in her Oct. 6, 2015  New Statesman review of  James Shapiro's newest Shakespearean biography,  1606: William Shakespeare and the Year of Lear  (Simon & Schuster, 2015) . Greer says: "For any writer of an extended narrative the temptation to abandon the conditional for the indicative is almost irresistible and Shapiro has not resisted it." Greer complains specifically about Shapiro's cavalier attitude toward uncertainties in dating Shakespeare's plays, about unwarranted elaboration of Shakespeare's relationship with London landlady Marie Mountjoy, about inventing the meaning of daughter Susanna's failure to take communion, and other issues. Greer said: With so little evidence, Shapiro is almost bound to overinterpret it. . . .  It is not easy for readers of 1606: William Shakespeare and the Year of Lear to determine when assumption becomes assertion, not least because Shapiro has chosen to provid...